For private equity firms and growth investors, the strength of a portfolio company’s finance function will significantly influence value creation.

Whilst operational improvements often take centre stage, a weak finance leadership team, particularly at the CFO level, can quietly erode performance, investor confidence, and ultimately exit value.

For example, in a recent blog, consultant Ben Grinsted, my colleague in the C-suite practice suggested that “CFOs are the critical bridge between an investor and the portfolio company”.

CFOs aren’t just driving the financial performance of the business to press down value creation into the business, they are the enabler in framing the data narrative back to the investor and act as an essential ‘yardstick of confidence’ from a performance perspective.

 

Recognising the warning signs early and knowing when to upgrade your CFO is critical.

Many portfolio companies can ‘inherit’ finance teams that were built for an earlier stage of growth.

The CFO you choose to ultimately steer the direction of the company is not the CFO you always start with.

What worked for a founder-led or early-stage business often struggles under the demands of institutional investors, complex reporting requirements, and accelerated growth plans.

As a result, finance leadership gaps tend to appear at exactly the moment when financial discipline and strategic insight are needed most.

 

The Early Warning Signs

One of the most common red flags is inconsistent or unreliable reporting.

If monthly reporting cycles regularly slip, numbers change after initial submission, or management cannot clearly explain performance variances, the issue often sits with leadership rather than systems or staff.

In my experience strong CFOs build what we call ‘reporting cultures’ that prioritise accuracy, accountability, and transparency.

Another warning sign is weak cash forecasting and, in high-growth or leveraged environments, cash visibility is essential.

A capable CFO should be able to produce reliable short- and medium-term cash forecasts, stress-test liquidity scenarios, and communicate risks clearly to both management and investors.

When cash forecasting is reactive rather than proactive, it often signals a lack of financial rigour and commercial foresight.

Limited strategic engagement is another indicator - a CFO should not simply report financial outcomes; they should shape them.

If the finance function operates purely as a back-office compliance team rather than a strategic partner to the CEO and investors, value creation opportunities are being missed.

Strong CFOs help drive pricing strategies, operational improvements, and capital allocation decisions.

They are embedded in the business, working with other managers and C-level leaders to understand wider company happenings.

The best CFOs have the soft-skills to be effective in this capacity to partner with the business, as well as the key skills to be able to portray the status of the business’ requirements.

Finally, an inability to scale the finance team to the operating model requirements is a major concern and should be a red flag for investors.

As portfolio companies grow, the finance function needs structure-clear FP&A capabilities, robust financial controls, and strong financial planning processes.

If the CFO struggles to recruit or develop talent beneath them, the organisation often becomes overly dependent on a small number of individuals and lacks resilience.

 

 

When It’s Time to Upgrade the CFO

Recognising these red flags is one thing; deciding when to act is another.

Many investors hesitate to replace a CFO, particularly if they have been with the business for years.

Loyalty and institutional knowledge are valuable, but they cannot outweigh the requirements of the next growth phase.

A CFO upgrade is often necessary when the company transitions from founder-led operations to investor-backed growth.

Institutional investors require stronger governance, clearer financial reporting, and forward-looking analysis.

A CFO who has only operated in small or early-stage environments may struggle to meet these expectations.

Similarly, major transformations, such as international expansion, acquisitions, or ERP implementations can often demand leadership with prior experience managing complexity and change.

Such transformational projects are essential to business growth.

Without this capability, finance transformation initiatives frequently stall or fail to deliver their intended benefits.

Further down the line, exit preparation is another critical trigger point.

Two-to-three years before a planned sale, investors typically expect a finance function that can withstand rigorous due diligence.

Clean financial data, strong internal controls, and credible forecasting are essential.

If the existing CFO lacks experience preparing a business for sale, upgrading leadership early can significantly improve exit readiness.

Good CFOs will understand the importance of the data telling the business’ growth story, in order to drive stronger exit multiples.

 

The Cost of Waiting Too Long

Failing to address finance leadership gaps early can have serious consequences.

One of the most immediate impacts is reduced investor confidence.

When financial information cannot be trusted or delivered on time, investors begin to question management credibility and the underlying performance of the business.

Operational decision-making also suffers.

Without reliable financial insight, management teams are forced to rely on instinct rather than data. Pricing strategies, hiring plans, and capital investments become harder to evaluate, increasing the risk of costly mistakes.

Perhaps the most damaging effect emerges during exit processes.

Buyers scrutinise financial data intensely during due diligence.

Weak reporting systems, inconsistent forecasts, or poorly documented controls can trigger lengthy investigations, price adjustments, or even collapsed transactions.

In some cases, the absence of a credible finance leader in front of buyers can directly undermine deal confidence.

Building a Finance Function That Supports Value Creation

Upgrading the CFO is not simply about replacing one individual with another; it is about ensuring the finance function is equipped to support the company’s next stage of growth.

The right CFO will build scalable reporting structures, introduce disciplined forecasting processes, and strengthen the finance team beneath them.

They also act as a bridge between operations and investors-translating financial data into strategic insight and ensuring the business remains aligned with its growth objectives.

For portfolio companies aiming to maximise value, the lesson is clear: finance leadership should evolve alongside the business.

Identifying red flags early and making decisive upgrades when necessary can protect investor confidence, improve operational performance, and ultimately drive stronger exit outcomes.

 

 

---

Camino Search is a specialist human capital and talent advisory partner to private equity investors and their portfolio companies.

 

Unlike many recruitment and executive search firms, we focus exclusively on private capital-backed technology and professional services businesses, partering with investors to solve essential hiring challenges, where experience in the technology/SaaS/AI and professional services ecosystems are vital to the company growth trajectory.

 

We believe that talent transforms businesses. As a result, we partner closely with the private capital ecosystem to appoint transformational leaders who align with growth and value creation strategies.